Demon’s Souls Prototype Shows a First-Person Future the Finished Game Left Behind

Before Demon’s Souls became the 2009 action RPG that helped define FromSoftware’s later work, it was still an experiment shared by Japan Studio and FromSoftware. A previously lost presentation from 2007 offers a rare look at how different that experiment could have been.

The material comes from Gameshare 4, an internal Sony event held in May 2007. Alongside a PowerPoint deck, the event included a roughly two-minute gameplay trailer, putting the prototype nearly two years ahead of Demon’s Souls‘ February 2009 launch in Japan.

Lance McDonald presents the material from a Japan Studio demonstration prepared for Gameshare 4. The accompanying notes introduced FromSoftware as the team behind the “real-time 3D classic” King’s Field, the 1994 RPG that predates Dark Souls, Bloodborne, and Elden Ring by many years.

The prototype’s presentation pitched its barren wastelands as photorealistic for the era, then filled them with creatures that never made it into the finished game. One unused design is a snake-like knight with a winding neck and unusually tall boots, a wonderfully strange idea that would have looked right at home in the game’s world.

The prototype also tested a first-person view

One of the most surprising parts of the demo is an optional first-person perspective, a clear connection to King’s Field. From that angle, boss encounters would have placed the player almost nose-to-chest with the creatures instead of keeping the familiar third-person distance.

The presentation also showed an Oblivion-style third-person control scheme, another approach that differs from the released game.

Only a small portion of the footage uses the first-person viewpoint. Most of the demonstration keeps the camera fixed behind the character, with the player model facing away from the viewpoint. That setup differs sharply from the finished game’s freely rotatable camera and lock-on system, both of which became central to the series’ positioning-based combat.

Early areas included familiar bosses and cut content

The gameplay takes place in an early version of the tutorial area. The Vanguard Demon is already found in a recognizable version of his arena, with moves and animations close to those in the finished game. Those design elements would later appear again in the Erdtree Avatars of Elden Ring.

The Dragon God’s arena is less familiar. Instead of the enclosed magma cavern from the final release, the prototype places the boss in an open volcanic crater. The footage also shows bipedal snake-like enemies that never appeared in the released Demon’s Souls, although their design recalls the man-serpents from Dark Souls.

Japan Studio’s design pitch also considered where online play belonged in an RPG. It described online games as too time-consuming, while fully offline RPGs were treated as limiting. Demon’s Souls aimed for a middle ground, keeping the journey solitary while using network connectivity to make the player feel connected to other people. The presentation even joked about the system taking less time than an MMO and referenced South Park‘s “Make Love, Not Warcraft.”

That idea appears through the ghosts and other player phantoms shown throughout the series. They represent people who died in battle, while summoned allies can appear when another player needs help. The presentation was already focused on the tension between isolation and companionship long before that balance became familiar in FromSoftware’s games.

The early concept art carries its own echoes of the studio’s later work. One image shows a broad ring of stone standing in a grassy field, an arrangement that recalls an Elden Ring boss area in Limgrave connected to a Stonesword Key. Another depicts a twisted dragon in a dark pit lit by red magma. The slides also include concept art for Flamelurker, although the scene may have been an early idea for that boss and also brings Dark Souls‘ Demon Firesage to mind.

The 2007 roadmap missed its planned finish

A development roadmap in the deck predicted completion in June 2008. Demon’s Souls ultimately launched in Japan in February 2009, several months later than that target. The slides also referred repeatedly to a worldwide release, despite Sony ultimately publishing the game only in Japan.

McDonald says Japan Studio’s notes framed the adventure around a simple contradiction: a player can feel alone without being truly alone, because other people are present through the network. That early focus on fear and fellowship helps explain why the prototype feels so recognizable even when its enemies and camera perspective look unfamiliar.

One commenter under the video compared the experience to watching the Mona Lisa being painted. It is a fitting reaction to seeing Demon’s Souls before its ideas had settled into the form players eventually received.

Tell us what you think about Demon’s Souls’ abandoned first-person direction and unused creatures in the comments. You can also follow us on X, Bluesky, YouTube, Instagram, Steam, and Telegram.